Proof of Impact
Alumni Survey Tells the Story
By Glen Slattery
In a skeptical world, proof is paramount.
Boys & Girls Clubs understand this. Potential donors want to know if they’re making a
good investment. Government officials need reliable partners. Educators, journalists and other agencies all seek evidence of effectiveness and impact.
Historically, emotionally and anecdotally, on a variety of levels, Clubs have long been aware of their own influence. But hard evidence – the kind today’s funders demand – is harder to come by. Now there’s Living Proof.
That’s the title of new materials, recently sent to Clubs for the first time, which highlight findings from a landmark survey across three generations of Club alumni, conducted by the world-renowned Harris polling organization.
The results are both dramatic and decisive. Former Boys & Girls Club kids tell about lives changed and uplifted by the Club experience. Most remarkably, 57% of alumni say the Club “saved my life.”
Areas of Concern
The Harris Survey findings identified four major areas of concern impacting America’s youth:
Crime and Substance Abuse: Crime, drug and alcohol use are among the most serious problems affecting our young people. Every 24 hours, more than 15,000 teens use drugs for the first time. Every two hours a youth is murdered. Every four minutes a youth is arrested for an alcohol-related crime. Every seven minutes a youth is arrested for a drug crime. Some 67% of Club alumni attribute their ability to avoid difficulty with the law
to the influence of Club staff. An equal number state
the Club is where they learned how to “say no” to drugs
and alcohol.
Dropout Rates: In 2006 alone, 1.2 million teenagers did not graduate from high school in the United States – that’s 30% of the class of 2006. The number increases to an astonishing 50% among some minorities. According to the Boys & Girls
Clubs of America alumni survey, some 28% of former Club members report that they would have dropped out of high school if not for the Club. In addition, 51% achieved a higher level of education than they thought possible because of attending the Club.
Childhood Obesity: According to the Centers for Disease Control, 16% of adolescents in the U.S. are overweight. This figure has nearly tripled in the last 20 years. Some 25% of young people ages 12-21 report that they do not participate in any vigorous physical activity. This lack of fitness means that many teens are at risk for heart disease, high blood pressure and diabetes. Of alumni surveyed, 80% said their Club experience had a positive impact on their attitude toward fitness and health, with 74% participating in organized sports.
“There’s an eclipse of traditional community in today’s generation: high rates of divorce, the decline of churchgoing and the fact that more people live in urban areas, where they may not even know their neighbors. Kids need a community where they are safe, where people know and care about them, someplace they can go after school and do their homework instead of getting into trouble on the streets. Boys & Girls Clubs of America is an organization that is able to provide that much-needed community for millions of kids.”
Dr. James Alan Fox
Author and criminologist
African-American Males: According to a 2006 New York Times article by Erik Eckholm, problems affecting many African-American males have become an epidemic. One-third await trial, are in jail or prison, or on probation or parole. More than 50% of black males in inner-city schools do not graduate from high school. However, according to Harris, 73% of African-American male alumni said the Club “saved my life.” Most impressive – 34% earned a four-year college degree, compared to the national rate of 16%.
When we consider the desired outcomes of Boys & Girls Club impact – academic success, good character and citizenship, and healthy lifestyles – all are apparent in the Harris Survey results.
Crucial to Brand Strategy
In a marketplace filled with many competing messages from the nonprofit sector, Boys & Girls Clubs of America will use the dramatic power of alumni testimony as part of its new brand strategy, being launched this year with the assistance of McCann Worldgroup, one of the world’s foremost marketing and communications firms.
The campaign will begin by focusing on high profile success stories – alumni such as BGCA national spokesperson Denzel Washington – and continue to reveal new stories of well-known alumni whose names will gain attention.
Just as importantly, the stories of “everyday heroes,” the vast majority of alumni who have become successful parents, teachers, police officers, lawyers, business owners, civil servants, doctors, nurses and more – will be told at the local level, bringing the message home in a powerful and relevant way that every Club can adapt and utilize. More information on this campaign will be forthcoming from BGCA.
A History of Results
The 2007 Harris Survey is the third national study of Club alumni by the organization, previous surveys having been conducted in 1985 and 1999. Time and the evolving role of Clubs have made differences in the data:
- More women are now included in the survey samples, with the rise of girls brought into official membership beginning in the 1990s.
- Educational data show significant increases in the number of Club members who went on to college.
- The once prevailing “gym and swim” view of Clubs has changed. Alumni are now just as likely to cite education and career development as central to their Club experience.
Humphrey Taylor, chairman and CEO of Harris Interactive, sums up results of the latest alumni survey as follows: “Clubs have both an immediate impact on members and a long-term impact on the lives of alumni, with benefits that many remember and value throughout their lives. For many, it was indeed the only place to go.”
Taylor cites the critical role that Boys & Girls Club staff and a safe Club environment play in making this positive difference. Most telling of all, the 57% of Club alumni who said a Club saved their life represent a 5% increase over the 1999 survey.
The survey results prove, even to a skeptical world, that Boys & Girls Clubs are more relevant – and more needed – than ever.
back to top